Vetting and analysis answer different questions
Analysing a creator asks whether the account can do the campaign job: audience, topic, format and expected behaviour. Vetting asks a narrower question: is there anything in this account that should stop the partnership, or that the contract has to deal with before anyone signs? A creator can be a perfect fit and still fail vetting, and a modest fit can pass it cleanly.
Keeping the two apart matters because they are often done by different people. The campaign team owns fit; legal, brand or compliance usually owns the gate. When one person does both in one pass, a strong fit tends to soften how risk findings are read. Our guide on analysing a creator before a collaboration covers the fit side in detail; this post covers the gate.
Related: How to analyze an influencer before a collaboration · Influencer selection guide
Write the red lines before you open the account
The most useful vetting document is written before any candidate is reviewed. It lists what ends a conversation, what needs a condition in the contract and what is simply noted. Written in advance, the list cannot be bent to suit a creator the team already likes.
Keep it short and specific to your brand. A children's learning app and an energy drink will not share the same list, and they should not. Each line should be something a reviewer can check against real content, not a value statement such as 'positive image'.
- Stop: content your brand will never appear beside, whatever the context.
- Conditional: findings acceptable with a contract clause, such as a recent competitor deal.
- Note: findings recorded for context that do not change the decision.
- Owner: the named person who signs off each category.
Related: Brand safety vs brand suitability · Ten brand safety rules
What the gate actually checks
A vetting pass looks at four areas. Content risk: what the creator says and shows, including spoken words in videos, not only captions. Commercial history: who they have worked with recently, especially competitors. Disclosure discipline: whether past paid posts were labelled the way regulators and platforms expect. Identity: whether the account you are talking to is really controlled by the person you are negotiating with.
Disclosure deserves attention because it moves to your brand once you sign. The FTC tells influencers to disclose any financial, employment, personal or family relationship with a brand, and its FAQ says advertisers should have reasonable programs to train and monitor the people who promote them. A creator who has skipped labels before is a predictable problem, not a surprise.
Identity is the quiet one. Before money moves, confirm that the account you reviewed is the account that will publish and that the person signing has authority over it. A short, temporary code in the profile bio, placed by the creator at your request, is a simple way to show control without sharing passwords or private analytics.
Sources: FTC: Disclosures 101 for social media influencers · FTC: Endorsement Guides, what people are asking
Related: Creator due diligence checklist · Sponsorship history review
Sort every finding into one of three outcomes
A vetting result should never be a score alone. It should be pass, conditional or stop, with each finding mapped to the red line that produced it. 'Conditional' is the most common honest answer and the most useful one, because it tells legal exactly which clause to add.
For example: a fitness creator passes on content, but posted a sponsored video for a competing supplement brand four months ago. The red line list says competitor work inside six months is conditional. The outcome is conditional, the condition is a written competitor ban window, and the finding is stored with its date and link so nobody has to search for it again.
Add a simple diagram: three columns labelled pass, conditional and stop, with two or three example findings under each and an arrow from each finding to the red line that placed it there.
Related: Competitor ban clauses in influencer contracts · Brand fit and suitability
Time the check around the contract, then repeat it
Vet after the shortlist and before the offer. Earlier wastes effort on candidates who will drop out for budget reasons; later turns vetting into a formality because a deal already feels agreed. If talks take weeks, the content you reviewed is no longer the whole picture by signing day.
That is why a short recheck before the campaign goes live is part of vetting, not an extra. It only needs to cover content published since the first review. TubeDetect produces the first review as a written report, and the methodology page explains what it can and cannot see.
A practical rhythm for a single campaign looks like this: shortlist on Monday, vetting finished by Thursday, offer and contract the following week, and a recheck of anything new in the forty-eight hours before the first post. The exact days will differ for your team; the point is that each step has a date and an owner.
Related: Pre-campaign creator recheck · Methodology and limits · Brand safety review
Keep the record, not just the decision
A vetting decision without its evidence cannot be defended later. Store the review period, the content sample, each finding with a link or timestamp, the outcome and who approved it. If the creator comes back for another campaign, the next review starts from that record and only covers what is new.
This is not legal advice. Contract terms and disclosure duties depend on your market, so involve your own counsel for anything that ends up in a clause.
Related: How to read a creator vetting report · See the sample report