Read the scope before the verdict
The first thing to check in any vetting report is not the verdict but what was reviewed. Which account, which platform, which date range and how many posts or videos. A clean result on a short window says much less than a clean result on a long one, and a report that does not state its scope cannot be compared with another.
Look for an explicit list of what could not be reviewed: deleted posts, expired stories, private content or videos without usable audio. A good report treats those as gaps, not as evidence that nothing was there.
Add an annotated diagram of a report scope panel with callouts pointing to the account, the review period, the number of items reviewed and the list of content that could not be reviewed.
Related: See the sample report · Methodology and limits
Treat the verdict as a summary, not a decision
Most reports open with an overall outcome, often something like suitable, conditional or not suitable. That is a summary of the findings against the criteria the report used, not a decision on your behalf. The brand still decides, because only the brand knows its red lines and its campaign context.
Check which criteria produced the verdict. If the report used a generic profile and your brand has a stricter suitability line, a 'suitable' result may still need a second look. Our post on brand safety versus brand suitability explains why those two lines differ.
Related: Brand safety vs brand suitability · Brand fit and suitability
Content findings: look for evidence and context
Every content finding should point to a source: a post link and, for video, a timestamp. Open a few and watch the surrounding minute. A word or image that looks alarming in a summary line can be a quote, a news segment or a joke the audience clearly understands, and the opposite is also true.
Separate observed findings from claims. Something the reviewer saw in the content is stronger than something a third party alleged. A useful report labels which is which, so you know what would change if new information arrived.
Pay attention to how findings are grouped. A report that lists twenty findings of the same mild kind may look worse at a glance than one with a single serious finding. Read the severity and the pattern, not the count, and check whether repeated findings come from one video or from across the whole period.
- Does each finding have a link or timestamp?
- Is the context described, not just the topic?
- Is it a one-off or a pattern across the period?
- Is it something observed or something claimed?
Sources: YouTube Help: Advertiser-friendly content guidelines
Related: Brand safety and content risk
Sponsorship and disclosure sections
The sponsorship section lists commercial relationships found in the period, ideally with dates, brands and links. Compare it with your competitor list and your look-back window; the report cannot know which brands you consider competitors unless you told it.
The disclosure section shows whether past paid content was labelled. The FTC says influencers should disclose any financial relationship with a brand, and in the UK the ASA codes and influencer guidance apply. A pattern of unlabelled deals is a signal to put disclosure terms in the contract and check captions before approval.
Sources: FTC: Disclosures 101 for social media influencers · ASA: UK advertising codes
Related: How to check a creator's competitor sponsorships · Free caption disclosure checker
Questions to ask before you act
Before turning a report into an offer, a short set of questions catches most misreadings. If you cannot answer one from the report, that is a question for the creator or for a follow-up review.
Write the answers next to the report rather than in a chat thread. A brief note such as conditional, competitor ban clause needed for one competitor, recheck before launch, approved by the brand lead, is enough for anyone who opens the file later to understand what was decided and why.
- Does the review period cover the time that matters for this campaign?
- Which findings are conditional, and what clause would resolve each one?
- Are any gaps in the content large enough to change the outcome?
- Has anything been published since the report date?
Related: Pre-campaign creator recheck · Disclosure clauses brands should require
Where the report fits in your process
A vetting report is one input into the gate described in our vetting process guide, alongside the fit review covered in how to analyse an influencer before a collaboration. Store it with the decision and the approver's name, so the next review of the same creator starts from what is already known.
TubeDetect reports follow this structure: scope, outcome, content findings with timestamps, sponsorship history, disclosure and limits. This guide is not legal advice; contract questions belong with your counsel.
Related: How to vet a creator before a partnership · How to analyze an influencer before a collaboration · Influencer analysis