How to use this checklist
This list is meant to be copied into your own review template. Each item has a short question and a note on what to record, because a ticked box without evidence does not help anyone six months later. Not every item applies to every campaign; mark those as not applicable rather than deleting them, so the reader knows they were considered.
The checklist assumes you have already decided the creator fits the campaign. If you have not, start with the fit review in our guide on analysing an influencer before a collaboration, and the vetting process overview that explains how findings become pass, conditional or stop.
Work through the blocks in order. Identity comes first because there is no point reviewing content for an account the other party does not control. Contract readiness comes last because it depends on everything above it. If a stop finding appears early, record it and end the review there instead of finishing the list out of habit.
Related: How to analyze an influencer before a collaboration · How to vet a creator before a partnership
Identity and account control
Confirm that the person or agency you are negotiating with controls the account that will publish. Impersonation and unofficial 'managers' are a known problem, and a contract with the wrong party is worth little.
- Profile link for each platform in scope, copied from the platform itself.
- Proof of control, such as a code placed temporarily in the bio or a message from the account.
- Who signs: the creator, a company or a management agency, and their authority to sign.
- Other accounts the creator runs that could carry campaign content.
Related: Agency workflows
Content risk
Review a defined period rather than a handful of top posts, and include spoken content in videos. Captions often look clean while the audio does not. Record each finding with a link and, for video, a timestamp, so the person deciding can see it in context.
- Review period and number of posts or videos reviewed.
- Findings against your red lines, each with link and timestamp.
- Context for each finding: news, satire, education, or the regular tone of the account.
- Content that could not be reviewed, such as deleted posts or expired stories.
Sources: YouTube Help: Advertiser-friendly content guidelines
Related: Brand safety and content risk · Brand safety vs brand suitability
Commercial history and disclosure
List recent brand partnerships and check whether each one was labelled. Platforms provide their own tools: YouTube has a paid promotion setting that adds a disclosure label at the start of the video, and the FTC expects influencers to disclose financial relationships, which includes free or discounted products.
- Brand partners in the review period, with dates and links.
- Competitors among them, and how recently.
- Whether each paid post used the platform label, a clear caption disclosure, or nothing.
- Affiliate links and discount codes, which also signal a commercial relationship.
Sources: YouTube Help: Paid product placements and endorsements · FTC: Disclosures 101 for social media influencers
Related: How to check a creator's competitor sponsorships · Free caption disclosure checker
Audience signals
You are not trying to prove an audience is real beyond doubt; you are looking for patterns that do not fit. Sudden follower jumps without a matching viral post, comment sections full of generic replies, or engagement that is identical across very different posts are reasons to ask questions.
Write down what you saw rather than a conclusion about whether the audience is real. For example: followers rose sharply in one week in March with no post from that week standing out. That sentence is something the creator can respond to, while an accusation is not, and it gives the next reviewer something to compare against.
- Audience country and language versus your target market.
- Follower growth pattern over the review period.
- Comment quality on a sample of recent posts.
- Any platform analytics the creator shared, and their date.
Add an image of a filled-in checklist row for each section: the item, a one-line finding, an evidence link or timestamp, and the outcome marked as pass, conditional, stop or not applicable.
Related: Influencer fraud detection guide
Contract readiness
The last block turns findings into clauses. Every conditional outcome above should map to a line here; if it does not, the condition will be forgotten. This is not legal advice, and your own counsel should draft the final terms.
TubeDetect covers the content, commercial history and disclosure blocks in one written report; the sample report shows how each finding is laid out.
- Competitor ban window and the list of competitors it covers.
- Disclosure method required on each platform.
- Approval steps before publishing, and who approves.
- What happens if a red line is crossed during the campaign.
Related: Disclosure clauses brands should require · See the sample report